Florida’s Sky-High Homeowners Insurance: Are We Entering a “New Normal”?
Florida homeowners have been holding their breath for years as insurance rates climbed higher and higher. Recently, Gov. Ron DeSantis and Insurance Commissioner Mike Yaworsky celebrated what they described as major progress in stabilizing premiums. But many Floridians are asking a fair question: If this is victory, why does it still feel so expensive?
According to experienced voices on the Treasure Coast, the answer isn’t simple. Rates may have stopped exploding, but they’ve settled onto a painfully high plateau—one that continues to keep Florida in the spotlight as the most expensive insurance market in the country.
The “New Norm”? Local Experts Weigh In
Harry Howle, insurance broker, real estate agent, and former City of Vero Beach mayor, describes today’s rates bluntly: “Once the cost of insurance is raised, overall, it seems to become the new norm.”
Homes in the beachside 32963 ZIP code remain especially challenging. Despite new insurers reentering Florida, many still refuse to write policies near the coast after years of catastrophic storm losses.
Tap to reveal: Why insurers are still nervous about Florida’s coastline.
Howle notes that while some policyholders are finally seeing minor adjustments—both increases and decreases—none of these changes are dramatic. Compared to the double or quadruple jumps in previous years, even a small shift feels like relief.
“I’d like to see more competition enter the state,” he said. “But I’ll take what I can get today.”
Older Homes Hit the Hardest
If your property was built decades ago or sits close to the water, brace yourself. Older, high‑value homes continue to see gradual but steady increases, even as statewide averages level out.
That’s partly because insurers now demand expensive upgrades—sometimes to systems that seem to be in perfectly good working order. Roofs, plumbing, electrical components… nothing escapes scrutiny.
Interactive Insight: Insurance companies now inspect everything—roof age, wiring, water heaters, breaker boxes, and more.
Howle refers to the process as “endless insurance inspections.” And even after all of them, homeowners may receive wildly varying quotes from different insurers.
Real Numbers: Beach vs. Mainland
Consider how drastically location and age can affect your premium:
• A $750,000 home built in 1970 on the beach: $8,200 per year
• An $820,000 home built in 2020 on the mainland: $3,200 per year
Another comparison:
• A 1991 beachside home with $1.4M replacement cost: $15,000 per year
• A $900,000 mainland home built in 2019: $2,600 per year
The numbers speak for themselves.
Lawmakers Push for More Transparency
Frustrated by persistently high rates, several Florida lawmakers are introducing new reforms. One bill targets “excess profits,” requiring insurers to publicly show the financials behind their rates—something currently shielded from public record requirements.
Another proposal would force insurers to break down cost factors behind every premium, giving homeowners a clearer picture of where their money actually goes. Insurers argue this data is proprietary—a “trade secret.”
Explore: How transparency laws could change insurance—and your wallet.
What This Means for Florida’s Real Estate Professionals
For agents, brokers, and aspiring professionals—especially those pursuing or renewing a license through Cameron Academy—understanding Florida’s insurance landscape is crucial. Buyers today are more informed and more cautious, and insurance premiums often make or break a deal.
Whether you’re entering the real estate field, renewing your mortgage or insurance license, or completing continuing education, staying informed helps you guide clients with confidence in a constantly changing market.
Getting licensed or staying ahead in your career can be a journey—but it doesn’t have to be overwhelming. Grab your favorite coffee or tea, take a moment to relax, and browse through our articles. Whether you’re just starting out or renewing your expertise, we’ve got tips, insights, and advice to keep you moving forward. Here’s to your success—one sip and one step at a time!
The Real Estate Board of New York (REBNY) has announced a new policy requiring sellers to directly pay the buyer's agent, effective from January 1. This significant shift aims to enhance transparency and address potential conflicts of interest in real estate transactions. The policy comes amidst ongoing lawsuits related to commission sharing and allegations of unethical practices. The implementation of this policy is expected to impact the real estate industry significantly, with sellers needing to factor in the cost of the buyer's agent commission when pricing their properties.
In a significant development, the U.S. Senate has voted to block the implementation of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau's (CFPB) small business lending rule. This decision has sparked a heated debate over the impact it may have on small businesses across the country. President Biden, in response, has threatened to veto the Senate's decision, emphasizing his commitment to fair lending practices and supporting small businesses. The CFPB's rule, implemented in October 2020, requires lenders to collect and report data on small business lending. This includes information on the race, sex, and ethnicity of borrowers, with the aim of identifying and addressing potential disparities in access to credit for minority-owned and women-owned small businesses. The Senate's decision to block the CFPB's rule has been celebrated by small business advocates and industry groups critical of the CFPB's regulatory approach. However, the implications of this decision remain uncertain, as President Biden's threatened veto looms large.
The world of real estate has recently been shaken by a wave of class-action commission lawsuits, sparking a contentious debate. These lawsuits demand scrutiny to understand their implications and validity. A primary counter-argument is the freedom of consumer choice. In today's digital age, potential buyers and sellers have access to a wealth of online resources, enabling them to undertake real estate transactions independently. Another critical factor is the negotiability of commissions in the real estate sector. Commission rates are not fixed, they are subject to negotiation between the agent and the client. This flexibility allows for open discussions, leading to mutually agreeable terms. Despite the emergence of discount brokerage firms, consumers continue to place their trust in traditional real estate agents. This preference stems not only from cost considerations but also from the value of expertise, guidance, and personalized service that agents offer. Real estate transactions are complex and often involve significant financial investments. Trusted agents provide invaluable insights, market knowledge, and negotiation skills, helping clients make informed decisions and navigate potential challenges confidently.
In the last two years, the housing market has seen a dramatic shift. Soaring mortgage rates and rising home prices have led to the fastest erosion in housing market affordability in modern history, with first-time homebuyers feeling the impact the most. The housing market has undergone significant changes over the past two years, leading to a substantial increase in the income required to purchase a median-priced home. According to recent data from Redfin, a homebuyer must now earn $114,627 to afford the typical U.S. home. This is a 15% increase from the previous year and more than 50% higher than pre-pandemic levels.
The housing market has shown remarkable resilience in the face of rising mortgage rates. Despite rates reaching 8%, new listings data remains steady, indicating a healthy supply of homes for sale. This stability is a positive sign for both buyers and sellers, demonstrating the strength of the housing market. Despite the increase in mortgage rates, sellers in the housing market have maintained their confidence. This confidence is reflected in the steady new listing data, as sellers continue to list their properties without hesitation. It indicates that sellers believe there is still strong demand from buyers and that the potential financial impact of higher mortgage rates does not outweigh the benefits of selling their homes.
The Real Estate Board of New York (REBNY) has introduced a groundbreaking requirement for sellers to directly compensate buyers' agents. This significant change has the potential to transform the real estate industry, eliminating conflicts of interest and promoting a more client-centric approach. This shift in the compensation landscape aims to create a more transparent and trustworthy environment for buyers. Moreover, this shift towards a client-centric approach aligns with the mission and values of Cameron Academy. As a leading provider of real estate education, Cameron Academy is committed to empowering professionals to navigate the evolving industry landscape and prioritize the best interests of their clients.
