The Morningstar US Active/Passive Barometer for 2024 provides insightful data on how active funds have been performing compared to their passive counterparts. Over the past decade, active funds have faced challenges, marked by consistent outflows and difficulty in outperforming passive funds. However, the total assets in US passive mutual funds and ETFs exceeded those of active funds for the first time.

Despite these trends, active management is far from obsolete. Active managers have managed to compensate for outflows through strategies like asset appreciation and fee bases during lucrative market conditions. Yet, the changing market environment could pose challenges.

Key Findings from the Morningstar US Active/Passive Barometer:

  • Success Rates: In 2024, active small-cap managers had a higher success rate (43%) compared to mid-cap (37%) and large-cap (37%) managers. However, over the last decade, only 7% of active large-cap funds survived and outperformed their passive counterparts.

  • Challenges in Large-Cap Equity: Only 7% of active US large-cap funds managed to survive and outperform passive competitors over the past decade. However, there was an improvement in their performance in 2024, with a success rate increase to 37%.

  • Success in Small-Cap Categories: Active small-cap funds performed better over the long term, with a 43% success rate in 2024, suggesting that the market is less efficiently priced in this category.

  • Real Estate and Fixed Income: Actively managed US real estate funds displayed the highest success rate among all categories with 47% succeeding over the past decade. In fixed income, active bond managers saw increased success rates in 2024, particularly in intermediate core bonds, corporate bonds, and high-yield bonds.
Active management remains a viable option for certain categories, notably in real estate and fixed income markets. The Morningstar report provides a comprehensive analysis that aids financial advisors in understanding the dynamics of active versus passive fund performance.

The original article on Morningstar discusses these findings in detail, highlighting the importance of the Active/Passive Barometer as a tool for evaluating investment strategies, offering insights into fees, market dynamics, and success rates across various fund categories.

Chart of actively managed us real estate funds

Global real estate funds success rate decline chart

Rolling success rates for active intermediate bond funds

More Articles

Getting licensed or staying ahead in your career can be a journey—but it doesn’t have to be overwhelming. Grab your favorite coffee or tea, take a moment to relax, and browse through our articles. Whether you’re just starting out or renewing your expertise, we’ve got tips, insights, and advice to keep you moving forward. Here’s to your success—one sip and one step at a time!

Title Insurance Leaders Double Down on Tech and Efficiency to Drive 2026 Market Momentum

The title insurance industry is entering 2026 with a renewed focus on technology, operational efficiency, and stronger agent support after years of volatility. Leaders from major underwriters report rising transaction activity, improved affordability, and a surge in automation and fraud‑prevention tools—signs that smarter systems and better training will define the next wave of growth.

Mortgage CEO Barred in 21 States After Major Education Fraud Settlement

A multistate crackdown has sent shockwaves through the mortgage industry as Patrick Terrance Donlon, CEO of Trusted American Mortgage, accepted a sweeping settlement that bans him from working as a mortgage loan originator in 21 states—19 of them permanently. Regulators say Donlon had another individual complete his mandatory licensing and continuing‑education courses, a violation that triggered a coordinated investigation and a $31,000 penalty. The case underscores regulators’ growing intolerance for education fraud and serves as a sharp reminder to industry professionals: cutting corners on licensing can end careers.

Florida’s Real Estate Slowdown: How Insurance Costs Are Reshaping the Market

Florida’s once‑booming housing market is cooling fast as rising insurance premiums, increasing foreclosures, and expanding flood zones push buyers to back out of deals and force sellers to cut prices. With insurance now adding thousands to annual housing costs, professionals across real estate, mortgage, and insurance are navigating a dramatically shifting landscape that’s redefining affordability in the Sunshine State.

New Florida Laws Taking Effect January 1, 2026: Key Changes Every Professional Should Know

Florida begins 2026 with a wave of more than 250 new laws now in effect, impacting healthcare, insurance, real estate, and consumer protections statewide. From free breast cancer screenings for state employees to tighter pet insurance regulations, mandatory healthcare refund rules, enhanced animal‑cruelty penalties, and new condo‑management requirements, these updates carry major implications for professionals navigating Florida’s evolving regulatory landscape.

Florida’s Barrier Islands: Why Paradise Living Comes With Sky‑High Risks for Homeowners and Agents

Florida’s barrier islands may offer postcard-perfect beaches and soaring real estate demand, but they’re also some of the most fragile and costly places to build in the United States. With 765,000 residents living on land that shifts, sinks, and takes the brunt of every major hurricane, the financial and insurance risks are accelerating fast. From billion‑dollar beach rebuilds to towers settling into the sand, today’s coastal development challenges are reshaping conversations around property values, disclosure, and long‑term resilience. For real estate professionals, understanding these risks isn’t just smart — it’s becoming essential.

Cedar City Builder Redefines Affordable Housing With Luxury‑Style Twin Homes

A Cedar City development is turning heads with its fresh approach to affordability. The team behind Temple View Commons is delivering luxury‑inspired twin homes at prices below the local median by using a small, hands‑on staff and cutting traditional costs like realtor commissions. In a tight Utah housing market where inventory is scarce and prices remain high, their strategy offers a realistic path to homeownership without sacrificing high‑end finishes.