The Morningstar US Active/Passive Barometer for 2024 provides insightful data on how active funds have been performing compared to their passive counterparts. Over the past decade, active funds have faced challenges, marked by consistent outflows and difficulty in outperforming passive funds. However, the total assets in US passive mutual funds and ETFs exceeded those of active funds for the first time.

Despite these trends, active management is far from obsolete. Active managers have managed to compensate for outflows through strategies like asset appreciation and fee bases during lucrative market conditions. Yet, the changing market environment could pose challenges.

Key Findings from the Morningstar US Active/Passive Barometer:

  • Success Rates: In 2024, active small-cap managers had a higher success rate (43%) compared to mid-cap (37%) and large-cap (37%) managers. However, over the last decade, only 7% of active large-cap funds survived and outperformed their passive counterparts.

  • Challenges in Large-Cap Equity: Only 7% of active US large-cap funds managed to survive and outperform passive competitors over the past decade. However, there was an improvement in their performance in 2024, with a success rate increase to 37%.

  • Success in Small-Cap Categories: Active small-cap funds performed better over the long term, with a 43% success rate in 2024, suggesting that the market is less efficiently priced in this category.

  • Real Estate and Fixed Income: Actively managed US real estate funds displayed the highest success rate among all categories with 47% succeeding over the past decade. In fixed income, active bond managers saw increased success rates in 2024, particularly in intermediate core bonds, corporate bonds, and high-yield bonds.
Active management remains a viable option for certain categories, notably in real estate and fixed income markets. The Morningstar report provides a comprehensive analysis that aids financial advisors in understanding the dynamics of active versus passive fund performance.

The original article on Morningstar discusses these findings in detail, highlighting the importance of the Active/Passive Barometer as a tool for evaluating investment strategies, offering insights into fees, market dynamics, and success rates across various fund categories.

Chart of actively managed us real estate funds

Global real estate funds success rate decline chart

Rolling success rates for active intermediate bond funds

More Articles

Getting licensed or staying ahead in your career can be a journey—but it doesn’t have to be overwhelming. Grab your favorite coffee or tea, take a moment to relax, and browse through our articles. Whether you’re just starting out or renewing your expertise, we’ve got tips, insights, and advice to keep you moving forward. Here’s to your success—one sip and one step at a time!

Portable Mortgages Could Rewrite the Housing Market

The Trump administration is considering letting homeowners take their low mortgage rates with them when they move—a major shift that could ease inventory shortages but disrupt mortgage‑backed securities and raise legal challenges.

Washington Fines Mortgage Broker Over $60K in Major Compliance Crackdown

Washington State regulators issued more than $62,650 in penalties, fees, and restitution to a mortgage broker after uncovering widespread violations, including inaccurate call reports, 79 webpages missing mandatory disclosures, prohibited advertising language, unregistered trade names, and improper borrower preapprovals. The case serves as a crucial reminder for all mortgage, real estate, insurance, and finance professionals to stay vigilant with compliance as oversight continues to tighten nationwide.

The Real Cost of Owning a Home in 2025: Zillow’s New Report Shows a Price Surge Buyers Can’t Ignore

Hidden homeownership expenses are climbing fast, with Zillow revealing that Americans now pay nearly $16,000 a year in taxes, insurance, and maintenance—up sharply from previous years. Soaring premiums, especially in Florida, and rising upkeep costs are reshaping affordability, slowing sales, and creating new challenges for both first-time buyers and seasoned homeowners.

US Commercial Insurance Rates Shift in 2025 as Most Premiums Rise and Workers’ Comp Drops

The latest Ivans Index reveals a mixed but meaningful shift in the 2025 commercial insurance landscape, with most major coverages—including commercial auto, general liability, BOP, property, and umbrella—experiencing year‑over‑year premium increases. Workers’ compensation remains the lone category trending downward. Rising claims costs, reinsurance pressures, and market capacity changes continue to drive rates upward, while Ivans’ new Benchmarks tool brings real‑time pricing intelligence to insurers. For real estate, insurance, mortgage, and business professionals, staying informed on these changes is key to planning, budgeting, and managing risk in the year ahead.

Mortgage Rates Dip as 50-Year Loan Proposal Sparks Big Market Reactions

This week’s mortgage update brought only a slight rate decline, but a much bigger conversation: the possibility of a 50-year mortgage. While a longer term could lower monthly payments by about $130 on a typical $400,000 loan, experts warn it would add more than $500,000 in extra interest and dramatically slow equity growth. With inflation still elevated and the Fed’s next moves uncertain, mortgage rates may edge higher heading into the season. Real estate and mortgage professionals should be ready to address client questions as this ultra-long loan idea gains attention, especially in markets like Florida where affordability remains tight.

LKP Finance’s Profit, Legal Battles, and Surprise Rebrand: A Wake‑Up Call for Today’s Professionals

LKP Finance reported a solid Rs 583.15‑lakh profit for Q2 2025 — but beneath the surface lies a storm of leadership changes, litigation over multi‑crore debts, a rare 12‑year‑old loan write‑back, and a full corporate transformation into Gyftr Limited. From compliance shake‑ups to a dramatic pivot into digital gifting and fintech, this quarter offers big lessons for professionals navigating fast‑evolving industries.