Rising Costs, Slowing Premiums: Why AM Best Predicts a Tougher 2026 for the P/C Insurance Market

Insurance financial analysis

After a relatively strong 2025 for the property/casualty insurance sector, AM Best is signaling a shift. According to new analysis reported by Insurance Journal, the industry may be facing a more challenging 2026 driven by slowing premium growth, inflationary pressure, and rising claims costs.

Premium Growth Slows as Rates Plateau

The momentum seen in 2025—supported by strong investment income and previous rate hikes—is starting to cool. AM Best’s latest industry report forecasts slowing net premium growth across many lines in 2026. This softening trend is expected to push the industry’s combined ratio up by 1.9 points to 96.9.

From cyber to D&O to commercial property, renewal pricing softened throughout 2025—and the trend appears likely to continue. Even workers’ compensation, traditionally a stable performer, saw its premium growth moderate last year.

Inflation Hits Claims Costs Hard

Jacqalene Lentz, Senior Director at AM Best, notes that rising prices for construction materials, auto parts, and commercial repair costs are pushing loss ratios higher. These macroeconomic pressures are cutting into the cushion insurers regained in 2025.

Even personal lines—which benefited from rate approvals and tech‑driven underwriting improvements—may feel pressure again in 2026. Higher auto fatality rates and increasing repair costs remain persistent challenges.

Commercial Lines Feel the Strain

Commercial lines are projected to reach a combined ratio of 96.3 in 2026—slightly worse than 2025’s 95.8. Auto, medical professional liability, and products liability each recorded combined ratios over 100 in 2025, indicating underwriting losses and ongoing stress.

Reserves: A Persistent Risk

AM Best’s re‑estimation of ultimate reserves revealed a $9 billion deficiency for year‑end 2024. While improved from earlier projections, reserve adequacy remains a major concern—and one of the clearest indicators of long‑term company solvency.

E&S Market Continues to Shine

As admitted carriers tightened underwriting or stepped away from volatile classes such as property and high‑hazard liability, the excess & surplus (E&S) market absorbed the overflow. AM Best calls this shift one of the defining forces of 2025—a trend expected to influence 2026 as well.

What This Means for Insurance Professionals

Whether you’re licensed or exploring a path into the industry, these shifts highlight the importance of staying skilled, informed, and adaptable. A year of flatter rate changes and rising claims severity means professionals will need sharper analysis, stronger risk‑evaluation skills, and a deep understanding of evolving market pressures.

If you’re considering entering or advancing within the insurance field, Cameron Academy provides flexible, career‑focused licensing programs designed to help professionals stay ahead of market changes and elevate their expertise.

To dive deeper into the original reporting, visit the full article on Insurance Journal.

More Articles

Getting licensed or staying ahead in your career can be a journey—but it doesn’t have to be overwhelming. Grab your favorite coffee or tea, take a moment to relax, and browse through our articles. Whether you’re just starting out or renewing your expertise, we’ve got tips, insights, and advice to keep you moving forward. Here’s to your success—one sip and one step at a time!

Fed Survey Shows Only Two More Rate Cuts Expected, Even if Trump Appoints a New Fed Chair

A new CNBC Fed Survey reveals that economists expect just two additional interest rate cuts in 2026 and none in 2027, even if President Donald Trump appoints a more dovish Federal Reserve chair. Strong economic growth, stable inflation, and reduced recession fears are keeping rate‑cut expectations limited, signaling a more stable long‑term environment for real estate, mortgage, and financial professionals.

15 States on the Brink: America’s Insurance Crisis Is Spreading Faster Than Anyone Expected

A nationwide insurance crisis is accelerating as climate‑driven disasters push premiums higher, force insurers out of multiple states, and reshape real estate and mortgage markets. Once limited to Florida and California, the instability now threatens 15 states where losses, extreme weather, and insurer withdrawals are creating mounting risks for homeowners and industry professionals alike.

Commercial Real Estate in 2026: Rightsizing, Cool Offices, and a Market Waiting for Clarity

Commercial real estate is entering 2026 with a cautious but strategic shift. Companies are ditching oversized offices in favor of smaller, higher‑quality spaces packed with amenities that attract today’s workforce. Downtown markets like Portland remain steady, while suburban vacancies rise and landlords get creative with incentives. Industrial real estate is cooling after years of explosive growth, and developers are hesitating—though multifamily and hotel projects continue to push forward. Overall, the theme of the year is patience, as businesses wait for clearer signals on interest rates, construction costs, and long‑term workplace trends.

The Real Reason Housing Isn’t Affordable—And Why Deregulation Won’t Save Us

A new study from leading urban scholars reveals that zoning laws and construction slowdowns aren’t the true cause of America’s housing crisis. Even with massive building booms, rents would barely drop for decades. The real culprit? Soaring economic inequality. Until the widening wealth gap is addressed, policies like upzoning and deregulation won’t make housing affordable for working Americans—and may even push prices higher.

Cambio Raises $18M To Transform Commercial Real Estate Workflows With AI

Cambio, a fast‑growing AI proptech company, has secured an $18 million Series A at a $100 million valuation, aiming to overhaul how commercial real estate firms process documents and make investment decisions. By converting messy PDFs, spreadsheets, and audit files into investor‑ready insights in minutes, the platform is rapidly expanding—now active in 35 countries and managing data for over 2 billion square feet of assets.

Florida’s Insurance Market Enters 2026 With Rare Good News — Stability Returns for Homeowners and Real Estate Professionals

Florida’s insurance market is finally showing signs of real recovery heading into 2026. Industry leaders say recent legal reforms have sharply reduced lawsuits, allowing insurers to stabilize rates — and even introduce reductions for the first time in years. With new companies entering the state and solvency at its strongest level in more than a decade, real estate and mortgage professionals may benefit from improved buyer confidence and smoother closings as insurance becomes more predictable again.