When Joe Karasin and his wife decided to swap the bustling streets of Chicago for the tranquil pace of Bolivia, NC, they anticipated a financial reprieve. However, the reality of their move was a sobering lesson in the unexpected costs of rural living.

Karasin, who operates a marketing firm remotely, found himself paying $2,950 monthly for a four-bedroom house in Bolivia—$250 more than their previous Chicago apartment. The couple soon realized that the perceived affordability of small-town life was an illusion. Their expenses were exacerbated by the need to reclaim their car, adding $400 in lease payments and $120 for insurance each month.

Their experience underscores a broader misconception highlighted in a Realtor.com article: that moving to the suburbs or countryside is inherently more affordable than city living. Hannah Jones, an economic analyst, emphasizes that while suburban homes may be cheaper in large metros, this is not the case in smaller areas.

In fact, data reveals that in 65 of the 100 largest metros, suburban homes are pricier than urban ones. This is particularly true in smaller Midwest metros like Toledo, OH, where suburban homes cost significantly more than those in the city.

The Hidden Costs of Suburban and Rural Living

Beyond housing, the Karasins faced unexpected costs, such as a $450 electricity deposit due to an “electricity co-op” they hadn’t anticipated. Their utility bills soared from $50 in Chicago to as much as $210 in Bolivia, even when air conditioning wasn’t used.

Moreover, the lack of public transport meant increased commuting expenses. “We thought about it and were like, ‘We’re not even saving money,'” Karasin reflected. “Why are we here?”

What’s Missing from Rural and Suburban Areas

As more people migrate from cities, rural infrastructures are strained, leading to increased home prices and a lack of conveniences. In Bolivia, the Karasins faced long drives for basic amenities, estimating they spent “thousands” on gas during their 10-month stay.

Ultimately, the couple’s lease couldn’t end fast enough. They moved back north, aiming to return to Chicago, wiser from their experience. “Our move to Bolivia was a mistake,” Karasin admits. “It’s one I won’t make again.”

This story serves as a cautionary tale, urging potential movers to thoroughly research and consider the full spectrum of costs associated with suburban and rural living.