New Reforms, Old Problems: Florida’s Insurance Market Still on Shaky Ground
Florida’s home insurance market has always been unpredictable, but recent reforms meant to stabilize the system appear to be repeating history rather than rewriting it. With insurers exiting, premiums rising, and new companies stepping in with questionable backgrounds, many homeowners and real estate professionals are once again navigating a landscape filled with uncertainty.
The latest developments trace back to Gov. Ron DeSantis’s 2022 legislative package—described by some as a seasonal gift to the insurance industry. Similar efforts followed Hurricane Andrew decades ago, and just like then, the result has been a wave of small, lightly capitalized insurers entering a market still trembling under the weight of catastrophic risk.
In 2023, Florida began aggressively depopulating Citizens Property Insurance Corporation, the state’s insurer of last resort. Citizens is required to shift policyholders to private carriers if the premium difference is within 20 percent. For many Floridians, this meant being moved into newer, more costly policies with companies that often lacked long-term financial strength.
According to the Insurance Fairness Project, some private insurers now assuming Citizens policies have ties to previous insolvencies. One notable example is Viceroy Preferred Insurance Company, sharing board members with Monarch National—an insurer fined $325,000 for mishandling hurricane claims and linked to the now‑insolvent FedNat Insurance.
“Many of the same conditions that left homeowners exposed in the last crisis are being reproduced.” — Insurance Fairness Project
Checkered Pasts and Rating Gaps
While many new insurers have been approved to take on Citizens’ policies, several carry histories of claim denials or financial instability. Some, like Patriot Select (formerly Anchor Insurance), reentered the market after prior restructuring. Others, such as Apex, emerged from the remnants of insurers that failed in earlier decades.
Compounding the uncertainty is the influence of Demotech—Florida’s most widely used private ratings agency. Despite awarding many insurers “A” ratings, Demotech-rated companies have historically failed at much higher rates compared to major national agencies. Between 2017 and 2025, 17 insurers collapsed within a year of receiving top marks.
Homeowners Paying More for Less
New data from independent agency Weiss Ratings paints a troubling picture: 14 Florida insurers closed more than half of homeowner damage claims without payment in 2024. People’s Trust Insurance Company topped the list, denying an astonishing 75 percent of claims. Slide Insurance Company, another recent entrant, denied more than half—despite holding an “A” rating.
Slide’s leadership also raised eyebrows for multimillion-dollar executive payouts at a time when policyholders struggled. Their opulent lifestyle, including a 9,600-square-foot waterfront estate, has only intensified resentment.
Political Currents Beneath the Surface
Florida’s insurance industry has long been intertwined with state politics. Substantial donations from top executives to political committees and allegations of regulators softening findings on insurer profitability continue to raise questions about oversight and public protection.
Climate finance strategist Jordan Haedtler argues that fragmented oversight across various agencies only deepens the crisis. His team proposes consolidating insurance regulation, disaster recovery, land-use planning, and building codes into a single streamlined authority.
Calls for a True Overhaul
The Insurance Fairness Project asserts Florida must move “beyond cosmetic fixes.” Experts like Martin Weiss go further, suggesting the state may need to reconstruct its entire insurance system from scratch to restore stability and protect homeowners.
For real estate professionals, lenders, and homebuyers, insurance reforms—good or bad—shape the trajectory of Florida’s entire housing market. Understanding the shifting insurance landscape is now as essential as tracking inventory or interest rates.
That’s why institutions like Cameron Academy remain committed to helping professionals stay informed, licensed, and prepared. Whether you’re earning your first real estate certification or expanding your professional portfolio, staying educated is your strongest advantage in a rapidly evolving market.
Getting licensed or staying ahead in your career can be a journey—but it doesn’t have to be overwhelming. Grab your favorite coffee or tea, take a moment to relax, and browse through our articles. Whether you’re just starting out or renewing your expertise, we’ve got tips, insights, and advice to keep you moving forward. Here’s to your success—one sip and one step at a time!
Cameron Academy is thrilled to offer the Free Annual Florida Real Estate Sales Associate 63-Hour Pre-License Course Livestream. This exclusive event is an opportunity for aspiring real estate professionals to gain expert instruction, access a comprehensive curriculum, and connect with a network of professionals in the industry. The course will be livestreamed from December 04-15, 2023, allowing you to participate from the comfort of your own home or office. Register now to secure your spot in this highly sought-after course. Spaces are limited, so early registration is highly recommended. Take the first step towards your real estate career today!
Coldwell Banker, a renowned real estate brand, has recently appointed Jason Waugh as the new president of Coldwell Banker Affiliates. In his new role, Waugh will be responsible for overseeing the brand's strategy, operations, and sales for its growing network of franchises. This appointment comes as Coldwell Banker aims to further strengthen its position in the real estate market. With an impressive background in the industry, Waugh brings a wealth of experience to his new position. Previously associated with Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices and Berkshire Hathaway Home Services Real Estate Professionals for 18 years, Waugh's expertise and leadership qualities make him an ideal fit for this role.
United Wholesale Mortgage (UWM), the country's leading lender, has increased its agency conforming loan limits to $750,000. This move, ahead of the Federal Housing Finance Agency's expected decision, applies to conventional and VA loans locked from October 11. The decision offers borrowers greater flexibility and access to larger loan amounts, with the benefits of conforming loans. These loans meet the guidelines set by government-sponsored enterprises like Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, offering lower interest rates and more favorable terms compared to non-conforming or jumbo loans.
PNC Bank has implemented a cost-cutting strategy, leading to layoffs and a shift in focus towards expense management and strategic priorities. The bank aims to streamline operations, improve efficiency, and reallocate resources to align with long-term goals. Despite the layoffs, PNC Bank is committed to supporting affected employees during the transition period. Learn more about PNC Bank's strategy and its impact on the industry at Cameron Academy, a leading career education school.
Government-sponsored enterprise (GSE) loan buybacks have emerged as a significant issue for lenders in the mortgage market. The sudden increase in buybacks from entities like Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac is causing financial and operational strain among lenders. The rise in loan buybacks is largely due to stricter underwriting guidelines enforced by these GSEs. The impact of these buybacks is significant and far-reaching. Lenders not only face financial losses from repurchasing loans, but they also encounter operational challenges. The surge in loan buybacks has created uncertainty in the mortgage market, potentially slowing down the housing market. In response to the challenges posed by loan buybacks, lenders are implementing stricter underwriting practices and enhancing their quality control processes.
The housing market is currently witnessing an unusual trend - a deceleration in the growth of housing inventory, despite the rise in mortgage rates. This unexpected development has triggered concerns among potential buyers and industry experts. With mortgage rates climbing from their historic lows, the number of homes available for sale remains surprisingly stagnant. We investigate the factors contributing to this unexpected stagnation in inventory growth and examine the implications of rising mortgage rates, limited new listings, and an increase in price cuts. We also consider the impact of external elements such as labor reports and geopolitical risks on the housing market.
